Blog Header Image

David Tatulli

   •    

December 31, 2025

The Biggest Mistake People Make When Getting Back Into Shape

The Biggest Mistake People Make When Getting Back Into Shape

As the New Year approaches, a lot of people start thinking about getting back into shape.

For some, it’s a fresh start.
For others, it’s pressure — pressure to undo the past year, fix everything at once, and finally “do it right.”

Unfortunately, that mindset leads directly to the biggest mistake people make when trying to get back into shape.

Trying to Change Too Much, Too Fast

Most people don’t struggle because they lack motivation or discipline.

They struggle because when they decide it’s time to get serious, they try to overhaul everything at once.

It usually looks something like this:

  • Training five or six days per week
  • Cutting calories aggressively
  • Adding extra cardio “just to be safe”
  • Expecting visible results almost immediately

On paper, this looks like commitment.

In reality, it’s rarely sustainable — especially for adults balancing work, family, and real-life responsibilities.

Why This Approach Backfires

When everything changes at once, there’s no margin for error.

A missed workout feels like failure.
A busy week feels like falling behind.
Normal fatigue feels like something is wrong.

Eventually, motivation fades — not because the person didn’t care enough, but because the plan required perfection to work.

This is why so many people start strong in January and disappear by February.

What Actually Works Long-Term

The people who make lasting progress do something far less exciting — but far more effective.

They focus on consistency before intensity.

Instead of asking, “How hard can I go?”
They ask, “What can I realistically repeat week after week?”

That might mean:

  • Training two to three times per week instead of six
  • Prioritizing strength and movement over endless cardio
  • Eating better most of the time instead of perfectly all the time
  • Choosing a schedule that fits their life, not the other way around

Progress doesn’t come from one perfect week.
It comes from showing up often enough for results to compound.

The Goal Isn’t to Win January

One of the biggest mindset shifts people need when getting back into shape is this:

The goal isn’t to win the first week, or even the first month.
The goal is to still be training consistently six to eight weeks from now.

That’s where strength builds.
That’s where energy improves.
That’s where confidence starts to return.

Consistency creates momentum.
Momentum makes intensity possible later — when the foundation is solid.

A Better Way to Start

If you’re thinking about getting back into shape this year, start with this simple filter:

Choose a plan you can repeat — not one that sounds impressive.

Boring works.
Simple works.
Consistent works.

And over time, those small, repeatable actions add up to meaningful change.

Continue reading